PaleoBios 20( l):l-6, April 15, 2000 1 20(10 I'niversin of California Museum of Paleontology Terminal Pleistocene armadillo {Dasypus) remains from the Ozark Plateau, Missouri, USA BLAINK W. SCHUBERT1 and RUSSELL W. GRAHAM2 'Geology Section, Research and Collections Center, Illinois State Museum, Springfield, II. 62703; 2Earth and Space Sciences, Denver Museum of Natural History, Denver, CO 80205 Seven osteoderms, tentatively referred to Dasypus cf. /). bcllns, were recovered from excavations in the entrance of Little Beaver Cave (LBC), Missouri. Morphologically, /). bdlus (beautiful armadillo) is a poorly defined species and its relationship to other extinct Dasypodidae and the extant D. novemcinctus(nine-banded armadillo) has not been adequately established. An accelerator mass spectrometer radiocarbon date (11,000 + 60 yr B.P.) on a buckler osteoderm from LBC represents a new terminal date for Dasypodidae in the contiguous United States, prior to the historic invasion by /). novemcinctus in the latter half of the 19th century. The LBC nonanalog fauna ranges in age from - 13,000 10,000 yr 15.P., and is composed of >3() mammal species with four extinct and eight extralimital taxa. Morphological similarities suggest that late Pleistocene Dasypus had thermal tolerance levels like /). novemcinctus. If this inference is correct, the association of a strong boreal component with Dasypus at LBC suggests high levels of equability (reduced seasonality) for the terminal Pleistocene Ozarks. INTRODUCTION The (jugulates (Dasypodidae, Pampatheriidae, and Glyptodontidae) first appear in the North American fossil record late in the Biancan Land Mammal Age (late Pliocene). Their arrival was but a small part of a faunal interchange that occurred between North and South America following the development of a land connection between the continents. In North America, the oldest armadillo remains of the family Dasypodidae are assigned to Dasypus bdlus (Simpson 1929) and are from the late Pliocene of Florida (Webb 1974; Robertson 1976) and Nebraska (Voorhics 1987; as Dasypus cf. D. bdlus). No other extinct dasypodids have been described from North America. Dasypus bcllns (beautiful armadillo) has been re- ported from over 50 localities, all from within the contigu- ous United States. The only extant armadillo in North America is the nine- banded armadillo (Dasypus novemcinctus Linnaeus 1758). Although this species currently inhabits much of the eastern United States, no prehistoric accounts have been verified from the region. The apparent absence of D. novemcinctus in the late Pliocene and Pleistocene of North America may reflect the true absence of this taxon, or could be a result of misidentifications of the larger form (D. bdlus) based on size and/or chronologic placement. Other than size, no morphological criteria exist in the literature for separating these two forms. If the gray area between D. bdlus And D. novemcinctus were not enough to cause taxonomic confu- sion, the lack of D. bcllns identifications outside the United States and existence of similar, yet uncompared, extinct taxa from South America, further emphasize the need for taxonomic work. Here, we describe fossil osteoderms referred to Dasypus cf. D. bdlus from latest Rancholabrean deposits in Little Beaver Cave, Missouri, and briefly discuss the taxonomic status and paleobiology of North American Dasypus. This record represents a terminal date for the /). bdlus form and currently marks the last occurrence of Dasypus'va the United States before the late Holoccne migration of D. novemcinctus. LITTLE BEAVER CAVE Location—Little Beaver Cave is located in south-central Missouri (Phelps County) among the rolling, cave-rich hills of the Ozark Plateau (Fig. 1). The exact location is on file in the Missouri Speleological Survey database stored at the Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Division of Geology and Land Survey, Rolla, Missouri. The cave is formed in Ordovician dolomite in the uppermost portion of the Gasconade Formation. The entrance is at an eleva- tion of 262 m on the west slope of Little Beaver Valley. The Figure 1. Location of Little Beaver Cave (clot), other Late Glacial (13,000-10,000 yr B.P.) records of Dasypus (triangles), and distribution of modern /). novemcinctus (shaded area) (after FAl'NMAP 1^94 1. 2 PALEOBIOS, VOL 20, NUMBER 1, 2000 passage length is relatively small (-150 m) and ends in a breakdown room. Overall, the cave can be described as a horizontal sinuous tube, choked with sediment. The en- trance area was enlarged through sediment removal by a previous owner during the 1960s and was used for storing vehicles and other supplies (Schubert 1997). Prior to this enlargement, sediments at the entrance were only about 1 m from the ceiling (Bretz 1956). The cave is discussed in more detail by Schubert (1997). In 1991, Milton Varney of St. James, Missouri discovered bones and teeth along the in situ unexcavated north wall of the entrance and sent some of the remains to Russ Graham at the Illinois State Museum for identification. The representation of extinct species in Mr. Varney's collection led to a small-scale systematic excavation of the site in 1994 and 1995. Fauna—The entrance deposit is the result of a low angle talus flow thai entered the cave through the current en- trance. Colluvial and fluvial movement of sediments from the overlying hill slope was the mechanism responsible for this aggradation. The remains in the deposit are highly fragmentary, probably as a result of carnivore digestion, trampling, and transport. Because any small to medium- size animal could have used the entrance area for various purposes, the taphonomy of the site is quite complex. The relatively low levels of corrosion, high degree of fragmenta- tion, dominance of small animal remains, and dimensions of the cave suggests that small mammalian carnivores are responsible for the bulk of the deposit (Schubert, in prepa- ration). The LBC fauna consists of at least 36 mammalian spe- cies, including extinct, extralimital, and locally extant taxa. Besides D. cf. D. bellus, the following extinct species are represented: Mejjalonyx jeffersonii (Dcsmarcst 1822) (Jefferson's ground sloth), Mylobyns nasutus (Leidy 1869) (long-nosed peccary), and Platyjjonus cotnpressus Le Conte 1848 (flat-headed peccary). At least twenty-three percent of the extant mammalian species recovered do not currently occur in the local community. Recovered extralimital taxa with modern counterparts occurring near or on the edge of the Ozarks are Blarina cf. B. brevkauda (Say 1823) (north- ern short-tailed shrew), Spermophilus (Ictidomys Allen 1877) (ground squirrel), Microtus pennsylvanicus (Ord 1815) (meadow vole), and Eretbizon dorsatum (Linnaeus 1758) (porcupine). Further removed and highly boreal extralimi- tal taxa include Tamiasciurus Troucssart 1880 (red squir- rel), Cletbrionomys Tilesius 1850 (red-backed vole), Phenacomys Merriam 1889 (heather vole or tree mouse), and Microtusxanthof/natbus(Leach 1815) (yellow-cheeked vole). Reptiles, amphibians, fish, and aquatic mollusks arc also abundant in the deposit but have yet to be analyzed. Additional reports are being prepared on the terrestrial gastropods, reptiles, and amphibians (Mead and Schubert, in preparation), and the mammalian fauna is described in Schubert (in preparation). All specimens are cataloged in the Geology Collections of the Illinois State Museum (ISM). Age—Seven accelerator mass spectrometric (AMS) ra- diocarbon dates are available from the Little Beaver Cave deposit (Schubert, in preparation). These dates range from - 10,000 to 13,000 yr B.P. One of the dates (11,000 + 60 yr B.P. CAMS-24426) was on a Dasypus buckler osteoderm like the one shown in big. 2. All dates were on XAD- decalcified (purified) collagen protein (Stafford et al. 1991). The target samples were prepared by Tom Stafford and the dates were processed at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's ("enter for Accelerator Mass Spectrometry in California. SYSTEMATIC PALEONTOLOGY Order: Xenarthra Cope 1889 Family: Dasypodidae Bonaparte 1838 Genus: Dasypus Linnaeus 1758 Species: Dasypus cf. D. bcllus (Simpson 1929) Material —ISM 492803, one complete imbricating osteoderm. ISM 495814, posterior section of imbricating osteoderm. ISM 595909, 595910 and ISM 595912, three undifferentiated osteoderms. ISM 595911, two buckler osteodcrms (one was used for an AMS date and was not cataloged). Description—The osteoderms follow the typical mor phology of specimens identified as D. bcllus (Fig. 2; Simpson 1929; Holmes and Simpson 1931; Kurten and Anderson 1980). Descriptive terminology follows Edmund (1985). Using the methodology of Klippel and Parmalee (1984), the complete imbricating osteoderm (ISM 492803) has a maximum width of 10.5 mm and a maximum thickness of 3.8 mm. These measurements place the specimen in the lower size range of D. bcllus, but still well above modern D. novemcinctus as measured by Klippel and Parmalee (1984). Three of the osteoderms (ISM 595909, 595910, and 595912) are heavily corroded and may have been digested by carnivores. Remarks—There is clearly a problem in the identifica tion ol\ Dasypus bcllus. It has been over 70 years since G.G. Simpson described D. bellus (as Tatu bcllus) from the Seminole Field site in Florida (Simpson 1929). In the diagnosis of the species, the only noted difference between D. bellus and D. novemcinctus was the larger size of the former. Simpson goes on to mention that D. bellus is apparently closely related to D. novemcinctus, but may be more closely related to extinct forms from South America. Since Simpson's work, no additional criteria have been given for separating the two North American Dasypus taxa. Our intention in this report is not to assess whether the two forms are conspecific, but to point out the tenuous nature of their separation. Species descriptions require morpho- logical criteria for justification and an etymology of the given name. The description of D. bellus is lacking both (Simpson 1929). Some attempts have been made to quantify size differ- ences in D. bellus and D. novemcinctus using osteoderms SCHUBERT & GRAHAM-LATE PLKISTOCENF. ARMADILLOS B Figure 2. Dasypuscf. D. beUusostCoderms from Little Beaver Cave. A. Imbricating band osteoderm, ISM492803. B. Buckler ostcoderm, ISM59591L Scale bar- 1 cm. (Klippcl and Parmalec 1984; Martin 1974). The high num- ber of dense dermal osteoderms in armadillos accounts for the abundance of these remains in some paleontological sites. Buckler osteoderms are highly variable in size and shape, and because there are so many in each individual Dasypus specimen, it is difficult to compare sizes. The moveable imbricating band osteoderms are fewer in num- ber and have been used to plot size ranges of D. novemcinctus and D. bcllus (Martin 1974: Klippcl and Parmalec 1984). For Rancholabrean deposits imbricating osteoderms identified as D. bellns vary greatly in width and thickness (Table 1). In general the sites with more specimens have a wider range of imbricating osteoderm sizes (e.g., Crank- shaft Cave, MO, width O.R. 7.9-18.4 mm, mean 12 mm, N = 221; from Klippcl and Parmalec 1984; table 3). Although some of the Midsouth deposits tend to have smaller average sizes (as noted in Klippcl and Parmalec 1984; Guilday and McCrady 1966) these sites also have a low number of recovered osteoderms (e.g.. Cheek Bend Cave, TN, width O.R. 7.6-12.0 mm, mean 9.9 mm, N = 10; from Klippcl and Parmalec 1984; table 3). Irvingtonian and Blancan sites with Dasypus are not numerous, but exceedingly large specimens have not been recovered. It is important to note that the D. novemcinctus measured by Klippcl and Parmalec do not reflect the extent of variation in the modern population, as only three specimens were analyzed. Thus the overlap between D. bcllus and modern D. novemcinctus will certainly be larger as more 1). novemcinctus comparative specimens are analyzed. Klippcl and Parmalec (1984) imply this when they note that the largest modern specimen they studied was approximately half the weight of nine-banded armadillos reported from Texas by Hall (1981). Because no morphological characters are known for separating the two North American Dasypus forms and there is an ever increasing gray area in size distinction, some identifications have tended to rely more on temporal and biogeographic assumptions. For these reasons, we tenta- tively identify the remains from I.BC as Dasypus cf. /). bcllus. Until a thorough osteological analysis of Dasypodinac is accomplished we will not understand the relationship of D. bcllus to D. novemcinctus or other large dasvpodines from other regions. Many basic questions have to be an- Tablc 1. Summary of imbricating osteoderm measurements from Blancan-Pleistocene localities and modern comparatives (from Klippcl and Parmalec 1984). Table includes the Blancan specimen from the Big Springs Local Fauna (Voorhies 1987) and the LBC specimen, both identified as /). cf. /). bcllus. Measurements in millimeters. Species/Age Localities (N) Osteoderms (N) Width (O.R.) Maximum Thickness (O.R.) /). novemcinctus Recent ---------- 342* 3.5-9.0 0.9-2.6 D. bcllus and D. cf. /). bellns Rancholabrean 14 474 5.9-18.4 1.9-7.1 Irvingtonian 1 21 6.2-10.3 2.7-6.8 Blancan 2 U 8.2-12.4 2.9-6.5 *Th c mod lern scutes are from three specimens which do not reflect the total range variation of the modern species. 4 PALEOBIOS, VOL 20, NUMBER 1, 2000 swered, for example, (1) whether or not D. bellus and D. novemcinctus arc clinal and/or temporal variations of the same paratypic species, and (2) if" D. bellus is conspccific with extinct armadillos known from South America. If the latter is the case, the generic status of D. bellus may need to be scrutinized as well. ZOOGEOGRAPHY, PALHOFCOLOGY AND EXTINCTION The smaller extant form, D. novemcinctus, is a recent northern migrant. In fact, there are no unequivocal prehis- toric records of its occurrence in the United States. Dalqucst (1967) reported /). novemcinctus from the Slaton Quarry (Illinoian) in Texas. Because of its temporal placement this specimen is now considered to be a small D. bellus (Kurtcn and Anderson 1980; Klippel and Parmalee 1984). The only prehistoric Holocene specimen of D. novemcinctus in the United States is an osteoderm roughly associated with a - 3000 year old charcoal date from the base of a clay unit in Miller's Gave, Texas (Patton 1963). The age of the osteoderm is questionable because the specimen was in surface sediments and could just as well represent an his- toric armadillo (Lundelius 1967). Furthermore, it is also possible that the dated charcoal has been redeposited. Dasypus novemcinctus began to expand its range into Texas in the mid to late 1800s and has continued to adjust its northern range (Humphrey 1974; Klippel and Parmalee 1984). The species now covers much of central and eastern North America (Fig. 1) where it thrives in warm moist environments, ('old winter temperatures in the north and aridity in the west seem to control its distribution. Because the two North American variants of Dasypus are morphologically similar, D. novemcinctus has been used as an ecological analog for D. bellus (Slaughter 1961; Kurtcn and Anderson 1980; Klippel and Parmalee 1984). The diet of/), novemcinctus consists mainly of insects (McBcc and Baker 1982), and it is thought that the availability of insect food must therefore have played a major role in the distri- bution of D. bellus. Reliance on insects implies that food sources could be limited by winter seasonal extremes, and thus survival of the species relied on temperatures above freezing (McNab 1980). In addition to the problem of starvation during cold spells, Dasypus have a high thermal conductance, a low metabolic rate, and do not hibernate, which makes even relatively short periods of freezing tem- peratures fatal (McNab 1980). Modern /). novemcinctus are quite variable in size throughout their range (Wetzel and Mondolfi 1979; Hall 1981; Klippel and Parmalee 1984). This confirms the no- tion that Dasypus is somewhat plastic in size. Although the larger Dasypus variant could not physiologically survive severe winter extremes (as discussed in McNab 1980), it seems reasonable that Dasypus under less seasonal extremes (particularly fewer number of days at freezing or below), in conjunction with an overall cooler climate, would find increased size advantageous (Bergmann's rule). It also seems plausible, knowing the rapid dispersal potential of modern Dasypus, that D. bellus could have had cyclic distri- bution fluctuations moving into more northern areas din- ing times of reduced seasonality. Dasypus disappeared from North America at the end of the Pleistocene. Whether or not this marks the extinction of a species or extinction of a variant that lives on today in the comparatively smaller D. novemcinctus has yet to be determined. The terminal record for Pleistocene Dasypus in North America is the 11,000 + 60 yr B.P. date reported here. Prior to this analysis, the latest date for D. bellus was from Blackwater Draw, New Mexico, where the youngest associated date was 11,040 + 500 yr B.P. on carbonized plants (Graham 1987; FAUNMAP Working Group 1994). Dates of -9,550 yr B.P. (Ben Franklin local fauna, Texas; Slaughter and Hoover 1963) and -7,200 yr B.P. (Miller Gave, Texas; Patton 1963) have also been given as terminal dates for D. bellus. These dates are now considered to be erroneous because they were either on weakly associated charcoal or conventional "bone collagen," which gives only a minimum date. In their review, Klippel and Parmalee (1984) note that many faunas in North America contain both boreal mam- mals and the "cold intolerant" Dasypus. Conventionally, such faunas have been interpreted as either representing a temporally mixed assemblage or an ecological community that no longer exists due to changes in environment and climate. New methods of radiocarbon dating individual bones using specific amino acids (Stafford ct al. 1987; Stafford et al. 1991) confirms that late Pleistocene commu- nities were composed of species whose modern distribu tions are disjunct (Stafford et al. 1999). This supports the hypothesis that mammalian species react to climatic and environmental change based on their own tolerance limits and that biological communities are far from static. Among the dated taxa by Stafford ct al. (1999) that were shown to have co-existed temporally, were D. bellus and the boreal Microtus xanthognathus, a species that is only found today in Alaska and Northern Canada. Approximately 2400 km separates the modern distributions of /). novemcinctus and M. xanthognathus. The presence of the relatively cold intolerant Dasypus with the boreal M. xanthognathus has been referred to as a nonanalog association (Stafford et al. 1999) and is strong evidence that reduced levels of season ality (compared to today) characterized some areas during the late Pleistocene (Hibbard 1960; Graham and Mead 1987). Although /). bellus has been recorded from numerous Rancholabrean sites with boreal mammals, the I.BG fauna is the first terminal Pleistocene locality with this disjunct association. The mammalian fauna from LBC is nonanalogous, with 23% of the mammals being extralimi- tal, most of which occur exclusively in more boreal habitats today. The strong boreal component in association with SCHUBERT & GRAIIAM-IATE PLEISTOCENE ARMADILLOS 5 Dasypus suggests high levels of equability for the latest Pleistocene Ozarks. The complete absence of Dasypus at the beginning of the Holocene in North America may reflect an inability of this animal to adapt to rapid climatic change and the onset of colder winters. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We wish to thank the landowner Debra Beaty and the Illinois State Museum for their support in the Little Beaver Cave project. Thanks to Milton Varney whom discovered the deposit and brought it to the attention of the Illinois State Museum. We greatly appreciate the excavation assis- tance of Rick Toomey, Dustin Schubert, Tom Stafford, Wayne Luzardi, Mike Held, and Bjorn Held. Our thanks are extended to Lee Anna and Sara Graham for help with screenwashing matrix. We thank Greg McDonald, Tony Barnosky, and an anonymous reviewer for their critical reviews and Jim Mead for comments on an earlier version of this manuscript. Portions of the Little Beaver Cave project were funded by grants from the Missouri Speleo- logical Survey, the Quaternary Studies Program, Flagstaff, Arizona, and the Illinois State Museum. LITERATURE CITED Bret/., J.II. 1956. Caves of Missouri. Missouri Geological Survey and Water Resources, Volume 39. 490 pp. Dalquest, W.W. 1967. Mammals of the Pleistocene Slaton Local Fauna of Texas. Southwestern Naturalist \2:\ 30. Edmund, A.G. 1985. The armor of fossil giant armadillos (Pampatheriidae, Xenarthra, Mammalia). Pearce-Sellards Se- ries No. 40. 20 pp. FAUNMAP Working Group. 1994. FAUNMAP-a database documenting late Quaternary distributions of mammal species in the United States. Illinois Stale Museum Scientific Papers 22, Nos. 1 and 2. Graham, R.W. 1987. Late Quaternary mammalian faunas and paleoenvironments of the southwestern plains of the United States, pp. 24 86 in R.W. Graham, H.A. Semken, Jr., and M.A. Graham (eds.). Late Quaternary mammalian biogeogra- phy and environments of the Great Plains and prairies. Illinois State Museum Scientific Papers, Vol. 22, 491 pp. Graham, R.W., and J.I. Mead. 1987. Environmental fluctuations and evolution of mammalian faunas during the last degradation in North America, pp. 371-402 mjW.F. Ruddiman and H.K. Wright, Jr. (eds.). North America and Adjacent Oceans Dur- ing the Last Deglaciation. Geological Society of North America, Boulder. Geology of North America v. K-3, 501 pp. Guilday, I.E., and A.D. McCrady. 1966. Armadillo remains from Tennessee and West Virginia caves. Bulletin of the National Speleological Society 28:183-4. Hall, E.R. 1981. The Mammals of North America. John Wiley and Sons, New York. 181 pp. Hibbard, C.W. 1960. Pliocene and Pleistocene climates in North America. Annual Report of the Michiaan Academy of Science, Arts and Utters 62:5-30. Holmes, WW., and G.G. Simpson. 1931. Pleistocene explora- tion and fossil edentates of Florida. American Museum of Natural Histoty Bulletin 59:383-418. Humphrey, S. 1974. Zoogeography of the nine-banded arma- dillo {Dasypus novemcinctus) in the United States. BioScicncc 24:457-62. Klippel, W.E., and P.W. Parmalee. 1984. Armadillos in North American late Pleistocene contexts, pp. 149 60 in H.H. Genowaysand M.R. Dawson (eds.). Contributions in Quater- nary Vertebrate Paleontology: A Volume In Memorial To John V.. Guilday. Carnegie Museum of Natural History, Spe eial Publication 8. 538 pp. Kurtcn, B., and E. Anderson. 1980. Pleistocene Mammals of North America. Columbia University Press, New York. 442 pp. Lundclius, E.L., Jr. 1967. Late-Pleistocene and Holocene faunal history of central Texas, pp. 287-319/;; P.S. Martin and H.E. Wright, Jr. (eds.). Pleistocene Extinctions: The Search For a Cause. Yale University Press, New Haven. 453 pp. Martin, R.A. 1974. Fossil mammals from the Coleman IIA fauna, Sumter County, pp. 35-99 ;';; S.D. Webb (ed.). Pleistocene Mammals of Florida. University of Florida Press, Gainesville. 270 pp. McBce, K., and R.J. Baker. 1982. Dasypus novemcinctus. Mam- malian Species 162:1-9. McNab, B.K. 1980. Energetics and the limits to a temperate distribution in armadillos. Journal of Mammalogy 61:606-27'. Patron, T.H. 1963. Fossil vertebrates from Miller's Cave, Llano County, Texas. Bulletin of the Texas Memorial Museum 7:1- 41. Robertson, J.S., Jr. 1976. I-atest Pliocene mammals from Haile XV A, Alachua County, Florida. Bulletin of the Florida Mu- seum Biological Sciences 20(3): 111 -86. Schubert, B.W. 1997. Paleontology and palcoecology of a termi- nal Pleistocene mammalian fauna. Little Beaver Cave, central Ozarks, Missouri. Unpublished Masters thesis. Northern Ari- zona University, Flagstaff. 188 pp. Simpson, G.G. 1929. Pleistocene mammalian fauna of the Semi- nole Field, Pinellas County, Florida. American Museum of Natural Histoty Bulletin 56:561-99. Slaughter, B.H. 1961. The significance of Dasypus lic/lus (Simpson) in Pleistocene local faunas. Texas Journal of Science 13:311 15. Slaughter, B.H., and B.R. Hoover. 1963. Sulphur River forma tion and the Pleistocene mammals of the Ben Franklin local fauna. Journal of the Graduate Research Center 31:131-48. Stafford, T.W., Jr., K. Brendel, and R.C. Duhamel. 1987. Study of hone radiocarbon dating accuracy at the University of Arizona NSF Accelerator Radiocarbon Facility for Radioiso- tope Analysis. Radiocarbon 29:24-44. Stafford, T.W., Jr., P.K. Hare, L. Currie, A. J.T. Jull, and D.J. Donahue. 1991. Accelerator radiocarbon dating at the mo- lecular level. Journal of Archaeological Science 18:35-72. Stafford, T.W., Jr., H.A. Semken Jr., R.W. Graham, W.F. Klippel, 6 PALEOBIOS, VOL 20, NUMBER I, 2000 A. Markova, N.G. Smirnov, and J. Southon. 1999. First accelera- tor mass spectrometry 14C dates documenting contemporaneity of nonanalog species in late Pleistocene mam mal communities. Geology 27:903-6. Voorhics, M.R. 1987. Fossil armadillos in Nebraska: The north- ernmost record. The Southwest Naturalist 32:237-43. Webb, S.D. 1974. Chronology of Florida Pleistocene mammals. pp. 5 31 in S.D. Webbfed.). Pleistocene Mammals of Florida. University of Florida Press, Gainesville. 270 pp. Wetzel, R.M., and E. Mondolfi. 1979. The subgenera and spe- cies of long-nosed armadillos, genus Dasypus L. pp. 43-63 in ). V. Eisenberg (ed.). Vertebrate Ecology In the Northern Neotropics. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington, D. C. 271 pp.